
“7 Myths” About Career Decision-Making
January 28, 2025
Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT)
January 28, 2025Guilt
Sometimes patients blame themselves for traumatic events, whether because of what they believe they should have done, or had to do! Or perhaps someone told them that everything that happened was their fault…
Some patients feel responsible for an event because they were doing something inappropriate at the time (for example, drinking alcohol before driving and having a crash in which a passenger dies); because they were the only survivor; because they had invited a sexual aggressor out; because they believe they caused their parents’ arguments or divorce; or because they think they failed to carry out a task (for example, believing they should have attacked the enemy and prevented a comrade’s death, or that they should have noticed a small, recently disturbed pile of rubbish concealing an improvised explosive device).
People who experience a traumatic event, in addition to the emotions they felt at the time (primary emotions and natural emotions such as fear and surprise), they may subsequently experience intense shame, guilt and sadness (secondary emotions, or constructed feelings). They therefore experience emotions arising directly from the trauma as well as emotions stemming from how they interpret the traumatic event and their role in it.
Primary (natural) emotions generally diminish unless something keeps them going. It is important to let people feel emotions relating to the event that they may not have allowed themselves to experience at the time, and to let those emotions run their natural course. Secondary emotions (constructed feelings) do not arise directly from the traumatic event, but from the person’s later interpretation of what happened.
Post-traumatic cognitive “chaos” is itself an attempt – more or less adaptive – to reorganise the belief system shattered by trauma. Previous beliefs about the self, others and the world are shaken, leaving the person disoriented and sometimes desperately searching for something that once existed but no longer does. Thoughts such as “I should have saved them” or “I must be a failure because I cannot get over this” can trigger self-directed anger or shame. These feelings are based not on the facts of the event but on interpretations. The more someone thinks about the event in these terms, the more such constructed feelings they experience.
Recognising that these feelings are being generated by thoughts can be empowering: by changing thoughts and interpretations, people can change their feelings and reactions. Consider an analogy: emotions are like a fire in a fireplace, full of heat and energy. Yet the fire eventually goes out if it is not continually fed. Self-blame and guilt-related thoughts can keep the emotional fire burning indefinitely. Remove the fuel of these thoughts and the fire will die down.
THE feelings of guilt becomes a a sticking point in the person’s recovery. Psychologists can use Socratic dialogue to help patients challenge these beliefs. Exploring the likelihood of different outcomes, regardless of the patient’s actions, can help resolve stuck points. In many cases, what patients did had little or no effect on what happened. It may be useful to challenge unrealistic beliefs about human capabilities. For example, in a military setting, how many people could detect small changes in the colour of a dirt road while travelling at 45 km/h in a partly enclosed vehicle, while also scanning their surroundings for every possible threat? Patients should be encouraged to accept the decisions they made at the time. Useful questions include: “Do good people always make bad decisions?”, “Do all bad decisions lead to bad outcomes?” and “Can good decisions sometimes lead to bad outcomes?” The aim is to help patients accept choices made in circumstances that, with hindsight, may seem ill-advised.
But they did not intend that outcome. Nor does the choice make them a bad person. An important treatment goal is to help patients fully accept their experiences from that time and understand that those experiences need not govern their lives.
The language people use when discussing the past can sometimes hinder their return to a more stable life. Patients often say they “should” have done this or that, “should” have behaved differently, or “had to” notice something or act another way. These expressions imply an obligation to act in a particular way. Failing to fulfil this “duty” suggests a specific “consequence”. “Should” and “have to” are words that shape behaviour and the person who believes they did not “do what they were supposed to do” sees this as a mistake or wrongdoing and feels guilty as a result.
“Guilt is an appropriate response after someone commits an atrocity or a crime.”
Note: A patient may need to accept what they did, feel remorse and seek self-forgiveness or, if religious, forgiveness within their church or another place of worship. Most religious institutions do not grant forgiveness without repentance. If the perpetrator has not asked for forgiveness, the patient has no obligation to offer it. Even if they have asked, the patient is not required to forgive. Understanding why someone acted as they did is not the same as excusing them. A patient may suggest that the perpetrator seek forgiveness from God through a place of worship. Forgiveness, if chosen, should be for the patient’s own peace of mind, not a pretence that everything is fine. Being pressured to forgive may only cause frustration and guilt.
As noted above, guilt presupposes intent: acting with intent. In many of our clinical cases, patients blame themselves (or feel blamed by society) and use self-accusatory language, confusing guilt with responsibility. Continuing to speak this way keeps them tied to the past and prolongs the emotions associated with the event.
Taking responsibility for one’s actions means acknowledging an unintentional act and its distressing consequences, which in many cases were unpredictable and beyond one’s control…
After structured cognitive work, patients are invited to revisit the past and address it using more up-to-date, constructive language, replacing absolute obligations with conditional expressions such as “I wish things had been different”, “I wish I had made a better choice” or “I made a decision under difficult circumstances and could not have known the outcome”.
Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT) is a structured form of therapy designed to challenge distorted traumatic memories, to change these beliefs and alleviate inappropriate emotional responses. It lasts an average of twelve one-hour sessions and aims to: (a) facilitate emotional expression and appropriately integrate the traumatic event into the person’s beliefs about themselves and the world; (b) identify and change unhelpful old thoughts and feelings; (c) accept the reality of the traumatic event; (d) make beliefs flexible enough to accommodate what happened; and (e) genuinely experience emotions related to the traumatic event. Various supporting materials are used, and patients play a central, active role in their recovery.
Ariel Milton, Psychologist

Founder & CEO PTSD Center






